Can All Plants Be Grown Hydroponically? Surprising Answers for Gardeners

As an avid gardener with over a decade of experience getting my hands dirty, I’m always exploring new and innovative ways to grow healthy plants. Lately, I’ve become fascinated with hydroponic gardening – the method of growing plants without soil by using nutrient-rich water solutions. With hydroponics, it’s possible to grow bountiful vegetables, herbs, flowers and more indoors or outdoors using a fraction of the space of traditional gardening.

But one question I often get from fellow gardeners is – can you grow ANY plant hydroponically? While hydroponics offers many advantages, the reality is that some plants are better suited for these systems than others. Through trial and error in my own hydroponic garden, I’ve learned that factors like the plant’s size, growth habits and preferences for wet/dry cycles play a role in whether it will thrive without soil.

In this article, I’ll share what I’ve discovered about which plants do best in hydroponic systems and which ones you’re better off growing traditionally in the ground. I’ll provide plenty of examples so you can decide if hydroponics is right for the plants you want to grow. I’ll also answer some frequently asked questions about hydroponic gardening to help you get started.

So whether you’re an experienced gardener looking to go soil-less or just getting into hydroponics, read on to learn which plants can and can’t be grown hydroponically. Let’s get growing!

What is Hydroponic Gardening?

As an avid gardener, I’m always looking for ways to grow plants more efficiently and with better results. In recent years, I’ve become especially fascinated with hydroponic gardening. This innovative method of growing plants without soil has many advantages that I’ve experienced firsthand.

In this section, we’ll dive into the details of what exactly hydroponic gardening entails so you can understand the basics of how it works.

Hydroponics Defined

Hydroponics is a method of growing plants without soil, using mineral nutrient solutions in water. The nutrients that plants normally obtain from soil are instead delivered directly to the roots in hydroponic systems.

There are several types of hydroponic systems, but they all involve growing plants in some inert medium like perlite, clay pellets, or coconut coir while the roots are immersed in the nutrient-rich solution.

The water and nutrients are actively transported to the roots using a pump and irrigation system, whether that’s simple hand-watering, flood and drain systems, NFT channels, aeroponic misters, or other methods.

Different Hydroponic Systems

Plants Grown Hydroponically

There are 6 main types of hydroponic systems used by home and commercial growers:

  • Wick Systems: The roots hang down into the nutrient solution from the growing medium above. Absorbent wicks transport water and nutrients upward.
  • Water Culture: Plants are supported above the nutrient solution, with roots suspended directly in the water. Air pumps oxygenate the solution.
  • Ebb and Flow/Flood and Drain: The roots are flooded with nutrient solution for a period before being drained. The cycle repeats multiple times per day.
  • Drip Systems: Nutrient solution is dripped slowly and regularly onto the base of each plant from above. Runoff is recaptured for reuse.
  • N.F.T. (Nutrient Film Technique): A thin film of nutrient solution runs through sloped channels, with plant roots directly exposed to the moving solution.
  • Aeroponic Systems: Nutrient solution is misted onto the roots at regular intervals from spray nozzles. No growing medium is used other than a root basket.

While that may seem complicated at first, hydroponics simply works by providing plants exactly what they need, when they need it – providing optimized conditions for growth.

Once you understand these fundamentals, it’s easy to get hooked on the many benefits and possibilities of soilless gardening. In future sections, we’ll explore which plants thrive in hydroponics and how to be successful using this innovative growing method. The world of hydroponics is exciting for both hobby growers and commercial farmers alike. I’m always eager to share my decade of experience with fellow gardening enthusiasts.

Which Plants Can Be Grown Hydroponically?

As an avid hydroponic gardener, I’m often asked which types of plants can thrive in a soilless system. Through testing a wide variety of plants in my home hydroponic setup, I’ve found that most common vegetables, herbs, and many flowering plants do quite well growing hydroponically.

However, some plants that require special growing conditions are better suited for in-ground gardening. In this section, I’ll share details on which plants tend to prosper in hydroponics and which ones present more challenges.

Most Vegetables and Herbs Grow Well Hydroponically

I’ve had great success growing all sorts of popular vegetables hydroponically, including tomatoes, peppers, cucumbers, lettuce, spinach, peas, beans, carrots, potatoes, and many more. Plants that produce fruits, roots, or leaves tend to thrive with the constant water and nutrients provided in a hydroponic system.

Herbs also perform very well without soil. The hydroponic herbs I grow include basil, parsley, oregano, thyme, sage, rosemary, cilantro, chives, and mint. I find hydroponic herbs grow faster, are more flavorful, and have higher yields than herbs grown in soil.

One tip if growing vegetables or herbs hydroponically is to select dwarf, bushy varieties that don’t require large root systems. This allows them to flourish in the compact hydroponic setup.

Many Flowering Plants Adapt Well to Hydroponics

An array of popular flowering plants can be grown hydroponically, which is exciting for home growers and commercial flower producers. Some examples that I’ve had success with include marigolds, zinnias, geraniums, petunias, pansies, snapdragons, dianthus, and even orchids.

The trick is to select flowering plants that naturally prefer moist soil and high humidity. This makes the transition to growing in nutrient water solution much smoother. I avoid arid-climate flowering plants like succulents, as they demand more oxygen to the roots than hydroponics provides.

Consider the Plant’s Size and Growth Habits

When deciding which plants to grow hydroponically, consider factors like the plant’s expected mature size, branching patterns, and speed of growth.

For example, massive plants like tomato vines can be trained to grow vertically in a hydroponic system, saving space. Meanwhile, sprawling squash and melon vines don’t transplant well to this soilless method.

Slow-growing plants also struggle, as the rapid growth in hydroponics can result in weak, stretched out growth. Focus on fast-growing annuals and smaller perennials to get the most out of your hydroponic setup.

By sticking with plants adapted to a hydroponic environment, you’ll be rewarded with higher yields and healthier growth compared to soil gardening. It takes some research and experimentation, but the results are worth it!

Which Plants May Not Thrive in Hydroponics?

While most common vegetables, herbs and flowering plants adapt well to hydroponic growing, some types of plants present more challenges without soil. Through trial and error, I’ve learned that large, woody plants and aquatic plants in particular tend to struggle when grown hydroponically.

Trees and Shrubs Don’t Do Well Without Soil

Larger woody plants like trees, shrubs, vines and bushes have extensive root systems that require the anchoring and drainage provided by soil. When grown hydroponically, the roots of trees/shrubs often become waterlogged and susceptible to root rot due to the constant moisture.

I’ve had limited success growing dwarf citrus trees hydroponically, but most trees and shrubs just grow too large for this method. They require wide, spreading root structures rather than just a cluster of feeder roots. Hydroponics also cannot provide the excellent drainage woody plants need.

Other challenges of growing trees/shrubs hydroponically include preventing them from becoming top-heavy and blowing over due to the lighter weight of the growing medium compared to soil. The rapid vegetative growth common in hydroponics also results in weak, stretched-out growth in trees.

Water Plants Prefer Still, Oxygen-Poor Conditions

On the opposite end of the spectrum from woody plants are aquatic plants that thrive in stagnant, water-saturated environments with lower oxygen levels. Plants like water lilies, lotuses and papyrus prefer their roots to grow partly submerged in still water rather than being exposed to moving, aerated hydroponic solutions.

I’ve had trouble keeping water plants healthy long-term in my hydroponic systems. The constant water circulation and aeration causes stress to these plants over time. They are adapted to grow in thick mud at the bottoms of lakes and ponds. The open water and “wet yet oxygenated” roots of hydroponics are too different from their native conditions.

Other Challenging Plants for Hydroponics

Plants with extensive taproots, like carrots and parsnips, don’t always form well in hydroponic media, which cannot accommodate their long tapering roots. Slow growing plants also struggle with the rapid growth encouraged by hydroponics. And finally, succulents and cacti that thrive in dry conditions don’t respond well to the constant moisture in hydroponics.

While hydroponic systems have their limitations, the variety of healthy, high-yielding plants they can successfully grow is truly remarkable. Focusing on fast-growing annuals, leafy greens, vegetables and compact flowering plants will lead to a thriving, soilless garden. With a little trial and error, you’ll be amazed by the vigorous growth hydroponically grown plants can achieve.

Frequently Asked Questions About Hydroponic Gardening

Over my many years as an avid hydroponic gardener, I’ve been asked every question imaginable about this soilless growing method. Here I’ll address some of the most common FAQs to help both hobby gardeners and commercial growers understand the ins and outs of hydroponics.

How Difficult is it to Start Hydroponics?

Many people assume hydroponic gardening must be complicated, with complex equipment and maintenance. The truth is, you can start small with just a basic pump, tubing, and a nutrient reservoir. Simple types like wick systems and deep water culture are quite easy to set up even for beginners.

That being said, larger hydroponic setups do require monitoring factors like pH, nutrient strength, oxygenation, and temperature. But starting out, focus on hearty and forgiving plants like lettuce, herbs, tomatoes, and peppers. This helps you get the hang of hydroponic fundamentals without too many hiccups. Don’t be intimidated – with a little research and experimentation, anyone can succeed with hydroponics.

What Are the Benefits of Hydroponics?

The advantages of hydroponic growing are numerous compared to traditional in-ground gardening:

  • Higher yields in less space
  • Faster plant growth and production
  • Lower water and nutrient usage
  • Less weeding and pest pressure
  • Grow indoors or outdoors year-round
  • Precise control over conditions
  • Easier to automate and scale commercially

By optimizing variables like nutrients, light, humidity, and airflow for each plant, hydroponics allows growers to maximize growth and quality. Plus, the enclosed systems protect plants, eliminating many traditional garden problems.

Is it Expensive to Set Up a Hydroponic System?

The costs of a hydroponic system range widely depending on the size, technology used, construction materials, and other factors. Indoor commercial systems can cost thousands to build and operate. However, for the hobby grower, getting started with a simple hydroponic setup can be very affordable.

Small hydroponic units made from inexpensive materials like plastic bins and PVC piping can cost less than $50 to construct. Upcycling household materials is also an option for DIY hydroponic planters. The main ongoing costs are nutrients, electricity for pumps/lighting, and replacement parts as needed.

Hydroponics can seem intimidating at first glance, but don’t let that deter you. With a bit of patience and experimentation, the benefits of greater control and higher productivity will quickly become clear. Don’t be afraid to start small and ask seasoned hydroponic gardeners questions as you go. The world of soilless gardening has so much potential for both hobbyists and professionals.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

As you can see, hydroponic gardening offers many benefits but also has some limitations depending on the plants you want to grow. For the vast majority of popular edible and ornamental plants, hydroponics provides the chance to grow faster, stronger, and with higher yields in less space. You can successfully cultivate an abundance of vegetables, herbs, fruits, and flowers hydroponically.

However, plants with extensive root systems or preferences for very wet or very dry conditions may struggle without soil. Carefully consider the natural growing habits of each plant before attempting it hydroponically. Focus on plants that naturally thrive in humid, consistently moist environments for best results.

While starting a hydroponic system may seem intimidating, you can get started inexpensively and simply. Have patience as you test different setups and plants. There is a learning curve, but the benefits of controlled, optimized growing conditions make it worthwhile. Don’t be afraid to begin small and ask experienced hydroponic gardeners for advice.

In the end, hydroponics gives you the chance to grow plants exactly how each one prefers. By perfectly catering conditions to each plant’s needs, soilless gardening takes cultivation to the next level. With a bit of practice, you’ll be amazed by the vigorous growth hydroponically grown plants can achieve.

Scroll to Top